Footage wasn't from 1991

[ciphergoth]

The wonderful Snopes is on top of it. The footage of celebrating Palestinians was shot on Tuesday, 11 September 2001 in East Jerusalem by a Reuters TV crew.

http://www.snopes2.com/inboxer/outrage/cnn.htm

They've got a whole page of war-related rumours:

http://www.snopes2.com/info/rumors.htm

probably worth checking out next time you hear a good one (eg Nostradamus). Most implausible so far: 4000 Israelis working in the WTC get a tip-off not to turn up to work on Tuesday, and not one of them breaks the vow of silence, not even, say, to warn a colleague...

http://www.thisiscyberia.com/NewsCenter/article.asp?ID=196628

Comments

I'm not stupid

[hbergeronx.livejournal.com]

I do happen to know that they have television and internet. We know people in Israel. I've worked with and even invested money in business there. I have legitimate doubts because although they may have been discussing Bin Laden in Edinburgh, we were speculating here in *NY* that it might be home-grown terrorists or reprisal from Saddam Hussein for the routine bombing the USA/(UN) forces do there periodically until at least one in the afternoon, NY, and no mention of Bin Laden. (I went home at that point). Patronising me is less than helpful. I want to know how the Palestinians had any certainty it was Bin Laden in such a quick time frame, as Snopes suggests. There are tremendous unanswered questions, and rather than honest questions and thought, I get the same old same old tripe from the left, and the same old same old warmongering from the right. Everyone's taking the piss at rumors and Nostradamus, and I couldn't care less- I want to talk about real options and what I need to make decisions regarding how I vote and act as an American. There are difficult questions at hand and I don't have all the answers and, in fact, I don't have all the questions!
So instead of treating me like an ignorant fuckwit, maybe you can attack my theory with facts to help me resolve honest, troubling questions. The snopes article merely disclaims it on the *word* of the crew that allegedly filmed it- not constituitive proof, IMO. I don't have access to a film library, I don't know anyone who can help me research nor do I know good keywords for even a decent Google search on the subject. I spent quite a few hours looking for stuff written by Osama Bin Laden (as Tamim Ansary suggests) and found *nothing*. At least I've read *mein kampf*- if Bin Laden is hitler, I'd like to read things written by him to try to hear his voice, undserestand his words.
At minimum, if you don't have data, you could at least have some modicum of compassion for me as I try to suffer through a deluge of conflicting information.