Instead of PKI

[ciphergoth]

Remember I said that PKI deserves to die?

This Clay Shirky essay states the problem with names in a really nice way (it's an independent reinvention of the ideas in this one but in clearer language)

Mark S Miller has taken the shape of the problem and shown that it's the shape of the solution! Here's how names should really be handled.

At first I thought "who would go to the effort of writing <pn>Alison</pn> all the time?" But the answer is, of course "anyone who can be bothered to write <lj user="purplerabbits">" - ie, it seems, nearly everyone who uses LJ.

This is really neat. And it's just become an essential part of my ideas on how LJ can become decentralised.

I can imagine the user interface already. You see a story that says

went to the cinema with ?Connor, who insisted we watch Spiderman.

Click on the "?Connor" and you get a little interface that tells you about the name in terms of names you already know.

* This user prefers the name Connor, but you already have a user of that name in the database (edit)
* Grant knows ?Connor as Daniel (accept)
* David knows ?Connor as Gingernuts Johnson (accept)
* Enter your own choice here _______ (accept)

[ ] Publish choice

Click on the appropriate "accept", and that name will be subsituted in that and all future appearances:

went to the cinema with Gingernuts Johnson, who insisted we watch Spiderman.

(U: replaced "?Ciaran" with "?Connor")

Update: A burst of nostalgia for the day we lost our naming innocence, just over eight years ago (and prescient words a few months earlier)

Comments

[ciphergoth.livejournal.com]

What, you have a special key bound to inserting "purplerabbits" in your LJ? I'm sure she'll be flattered - or worried :-)

My client doesn't do any of that kind of thing; and anyway, it doesn't take over when I'm writing responses, which is annoying (though of course very difficult to fix). But anyway, the point stands either way - users *can* be bothered to go through a little parecky in order to make names more useful, whether that's typing in markup or highlighting the name and pressing "mark as name".