Only traitors try to make us afraid of terrorists

[ciphergoth]

Quoted in full because this is important. I've corrected an error in his quote from the paper.

Only traitors try to make us afraid of terrorists

In this mind-blowing, exhaustively researched Cato institute paper by Ohio State University's John Mueller, the case against being afraid of terrorism is laid out in irrefutable logic, backed with credible, documented statistics about terrorism's risks. From the number of fatalities produced by terrorism to the trends in terrorism death to the fact that almost no one has ever died from a military biological agent to the fact that poison gas and dirty bombs in the field do only minor damage -- this paper is the most reassuring and infuriating piece of analysis I've read since September 11th, 2001.

The bottom line is, terrorism doesn't kill many people. Even in Israel, you're four times more likely to die in a car wreck than as a result of a terrorist attack. In the USA, you need to be more worried about lightning strikes than terrorism. The point of terrorism is to create terror, and by cynically convincing us that our very countries are at risk from terrorism, our politicians have delivered utter victory to the terrorists: we are terrified.

Much of the current alarm is generated from the knowledge that many of today's terrorists simply want to kill, and kill more or less randomly, for revenge or as an act of what they take to be war.

[...] The shock and tragedy of September 11 does demand a focused and dedicated program to confront international terrorism and to attempt to prevent a repeat. But it seems sensible to suggest that part of this reaction should include an effort by politicians, officials, and the media to inform the public reasonably and realistically about the terrorist context instead of playing into the hands of terrorists by frightening the public. What is needed, as one statistician suggests, is some sort of convincing, coherent, informed, and nuanced answer to a central question: "How worried should I be?" Instead, the message the nation has received so far is, as a Homeland Security official put (or caricatured) it, "Be scared; be very, very scared -- but go on with your lives." Such messages have led many people to develop what Leif Wenar of the University of Sheffield has aptly labeled "a false sense of insecurity."

-- Cory Doctorow, Boing Boing

A False Sense of Insecurity (PDF, see also HTML version), John Mueller, Ohio State University

Comments

[ladycat.livejournal.com]

Yes, but there's one vital error. The people who need to read this are too busy running round screaming *PANIC* *FEAR* *DREAD* and reading the Daily Mail...

[vvalkyri.livejournal.com]

And then there's this morning's reports re the airline plot.

[vampire-kitten.livejournal.com]

Current terror alert level: Cup of tea, nice biscuit and a sit down needed.

[ladycat.livejournal.com]

I'm ashamed to admit that I freaked out yesterday morning and asked my partner to cycle to work in case the bombers changed their plans and bombed the tube again. Then I realised that *far* more cyclists die on the road every year and panicked about that instead. Of course it's far easier to worry about his safety than to consider my own, working with a project where DV perpetrators and traffickers are the order of the day!