Grammar queen

[ciphergoth]

English usage question arising out of a discussion on a wiki. I have my own opinion, but I don't want to bias the poll, so here it is...

[Poll #681358]

Comments

[hughe.livejournal.com]

it does depend on the storey i supose... but i dont think "the pilot" is proper enough top be capitalised...

For example i would capitalise "The Black Pirate", but not "the pirate"

Or alternativley, i could say "He asked Pilot where they were".